A historic painting depicting Jesus rescuing sailors has recently resurfaced at the U.S. Merchant Marine Academy (USMMA) in Kings Point, New York. The artwork, titled "Christ on the Water," was removed from the chapel basement where it had been placed following a controversial complaint. This move has sparked a wave of support among midshipmen and advocates for religious expression.
Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy announced the painting’s return to prominence, celebrating the decision on social media. "All glory to God! ‘Christ on the Water’ is out of the basement," Duffy tweeted, sharing a photo of the painting. He emphasized that religious expression should be celebrated rather than condemned, a sentiment echoed by many at the academy.
Originally painted in 1944, "Christ on the Water" had adorned the walls of Wiley Hall for 76 years. However, a complaint from the Military Religious Freedom Foundation (MRFF) led to its removal, citing a violation of the Establishment Clause of the First Amendment. Critics claimed the presence of the painting in a government institution could alienate non-Christian students.
The controversy surrounding the painting intensified after Duffy’s speech at the academy’s annual Battle Standard Dinner in April, where he called for its restoration. His remarks were met with enthusiastic applause from midshipmen, highlighting the painting’s significance to their spiritual and emotional well-being. One midshipman reflected, "I remember many times when I used to pray underneath that painting when I was on the verge of failing a class or worried about something. It’s a very significant part of our history."
The painting’s relocation has not been without opposition. Mikey Weinstein, founder of the MRFF, has been vocal in his criticism, accusing Duffy of promoting Christian nationalism. Weinstein’s statements have drawn attention to the ongoing debate over the separation of church and state, particularly in military and educational institutions.
Despite the challenges, many supporters of the painting argue that it symbolizes hope and divine protection. The painting has become more than just an artwork; it represents a source of comfort for midshipmen facing the pressures of military training and academic challenges.
Duffy, who has also displayed a replica of the painting in his office at the U.S. Department of Transportation, defended the painting’s place at the academy. He pointed out that the focus should be on addressing the pressing issues within the academy, including infrastructure concerns that have left midshipmen without basic amenities like hot water.
As the painting undergoes restoration, it remains a focal point of discussion about religious expression in public institutions. Supporters hope that "Christ on the Water" will soon find its rightful place, inspiring future generations of midshipmen and serving as a reminder of faith amid life’s storms.
In these times of division and debate, the return of "Christ on the Water" serves as a reminder of the importance of faith and community in our lives. Whether one views the painting as a symbol of Christian nationalism or a cherished piece of history, it undeniably holds a special place in the hearts of many at the USMMA.
For more on the significance of religious expression in military settings, you can read about the ongoing discussions at the Military Religious Freedom Foundation.