In a recent episode of the "CrossPolitic" podcast, Pastor Toby Sumpter of King’s Cross Church in Moscow, Idaho, stirred significant discussion by asserting that women forfeit their right to vote upon marriage. This controversial statement, linked to the broader Christian nationalist movement, has raised eyebrows and sparked lively debate within and outside of the Christian community.
Sumpter, who is associated with self-identified Christian nationalist Douglas Wilson, argued that the 19th Amendment, which granted women the right to vote in the United States, should be repealed. He contended that the concept of voting is fundamentally flawed when it comes to the role of women in the family structure. “When you get married, you are essentially choosing a representative,” Sumpter stated, suggesting that a woman’s choice of a husband is akin to selecting a political representative who then votes on her behalf.
During the podcast, Sumpter expressed the notion that women’s voting rights are limited in the context of a constitutional republic. He elaborated, “Women are not allowed to vote for any bill in Congress; only elected representatives and senators can vote.” This perspective has raised questions about the implications of his views on gender roles and civic engagement.
In a blog post on his website, Sumpter further explored his views, reminiscing about a time before the suffrage movement when he believes women were held in high regard. He posited that the family unit is foundational to society, emphasizing the importance of traditional roles within the home. “God made the world in such a way that it flourishes when we run along those grooves,” he wrote, advocating for a return to what he sees as the biblical design for family and society.
Sumpter also pointed to historical examples from the New Testament, referencing Lydia, a prominent figure in early Christianity who led her household. He argued that in church settings, voting often occurs by household, which includes women who may be single, widowed, or divorced. “The issue isn’t male vs. female; it’s household vs. societal fragmentation,” he remarked, suggesting that the focus should be on the integrity of family units rather than on gender-based voting rights.
This discourse has attracted attention not only for its content but also for its implications on contemporary gender dynamics within Christianity. Critics argue that such views could undermine the progress made in women’s rights, while supporters may see it as a return to traditional values.
Pastor Sumpter’s remarks come on the heels of a broader conversation within certain Christian circles about the role of women in society. Douglas Wilson, a well-known figure in Christian nationalist thought, has also expressed similar sentiments in various platforms, including a recent interview with CNN where he stated, “Women are the kind of people that people come out of.” His comments have drawn both support and criticism, leading to a wider discussion about the intersection of faith, politics, and gender.
As these discussions unfold, it’s clear that the dialogue surrounding women’s rights, traditional family roles, and the influence of Christian nationalism is far from over. The implications of these views extend beyond theological debates, touching on cultural, social, and political realms as well.
For those interested in exploring the broader context of these discussions, resources such as the Christianity Today and The Gospel Coalition provide valuable insights into the evolving conversation around faith and societal roles.
As the conversation continues, it remains essential for believers and non-believers alike to engage thoughtfully with these perspectives, considering their implications for both the church and society at large.