Does God Bring About Evil?

In a world filled with uncertainties and challenges, the question of divine sovereignty remains a hot topic among theologians and believers alike. The late R.C. Sproul, a renowned Presbyterian pastor and educator, often posed a thought-provoking challenge to his seminary students regarding the Westminster Confession of Faith. He would read a statement about God’s eternal decree and then ask, “How many of you believe that statement?” The responses were telling: many hands would rise, but a few would hesitate. Sproul would then ask, “How many of you are atheists?” The silence that followed was palpable, and it set the stage for a deeper discussion about the nature of God’s sovereignty.

Sproul’s intention was clear: he believed that to deny God’s absolute control over all events is to misunderstand the very essence of the God described in Scripture. This doctrine, often referred to as “divine determinism,” posits that God meticulously orchestrates every occurrence in the universe. But is this perspective biblically sound?

A key passage that supporters of divine determinism often cite is Genesis 50:20, where Joseph tells his brothers, “You meant evil against me, but God meant it for good.” This verse is frequently interpreted to mean that even the malicious actions of Joseph’s brothers were part of God’s predetermined plan to save many lives during a famine. However, this raises important questions: Does this mean God orchestrated their sinful actions, or is there a more nuanced understanding?

Examining the Hebrew word ḥāšaḇ, translated as “meant,” reveals a broader context. While the brothers intended harm, the same word is used elsewhere in Scripture to describe skilled craftsmanship, such as in the construction of the tabernacle (Exodus 28:6, Exodus 36:8). This suggests that God can take the raw materials of human actions—both good and evil—and skillfully work them into something beautiful.

Rather than viewing God as a divine puppeteer, it may be more accurate to see Him as a master craftsman who works all things together for good (Romans 8:28). God’s sovereignty does not negate human responsibility; instead, it emphasizes His ability to bring about His purposes through our choices, even when those choices are flawed.

The concept of God’s sovereignty is indeed complex, but it is essential to recognize that while God can and does intervene in history, His typical method is to work through the free will of individuals. Acts 2:23 and Acts 4:27-28 affirm that God predetermined certain events, but these instances appear to be exceptional rather than the norm. Most often, the divine plan unfolds through the ordinary, sometimes messy, choices of humanity.

In this light, the idea that God can take our brokenness and weave it into a greater narrative of redemption aligns beautifully with the character of a loving God. Just as a skilled chef can create a delicious omelet from broken eggs, so too can God create something magnificent from our struggles and failures.

As believers, we can find comfort in the assurance that God is sovereign over all creation, skillfully working through the events of our lives to fulfill His divine purposes. This understanding invites us to trust Him more deeply, knowing that even in our darkest moments, He is at work, crafting a story that ultimately leads to good.

For further exploration of God’s sovereignty and its implications for our lives, consider visiting The Gospel Coalition or Desiring God for a wealth of resources and insights.

In conclusion, while the debate over divine determinism and human free will continues, one thing remains clear: God’s sovereignty is a source of hope and assurance for believers. He is not only aware of our circumstances but is actively involved in shaping our lives for His glory and our good.