In a heart-wrenching incident that has left the small community of Seneca, Kansas, reeling, beloved priest Father Arul Carasala was tragically shot and killed outside the rectory of Saints Peter and Paul Catholic Church. This shocking event unfolded on Thursday afternoon, sending ripples of grief throughout the parish and beyond.
Witnesses were left in disbelief as they recounted the moments leading up to the shooting. Betty Haug, who was in her backyard, saw the alleged shooter, Gary Lee Hermesch, 66, approach Father Carasala and fire multiple shots. Hermesch, who has ties to the area but had been living in Tulsa, Oklahoma, reportedly shot Carasala three times before turning himself in to the Nemaha County Sheriff’s Office, just a short distance away.
Father Carasala was rushed to a local hospital but succumbed to his injuries shortly thereafter. Originally from India, he had been a cherished member of the Seneca community since 2011, serving as the pastor of Saints Peter and Paul Catholic Church. His ordination as a priest took place in 1994, and he became a U.S. citizen in 2011, reflecting his deep commitment to his faith and community. He was also known for his role as dean of the Nemaha-Marshall region within the Archdiocese of Kansas City in Kansas.
As news of the tragedy spread, parishioners quickly came together to honor Father Carasala’s legacy. A mass and rosary service were organized on short notice, drawing a large crowd of mourners who came to pay their respects. Community members visited the rectory, leaving flowers and heartfelt tokens of remembrance at the doorstep, a poignant reminder of the impact Father Carasala had on their lives.
Greg Kohake, a parishioner and member of the Seneca Knights of Columbus, shared his sorrow, describing Father Carasala not just as a pastor but as a dear friend. Kohake emphasized the importance of prayer, not only for the grieving community but also for the perpetrator, highlighting the Christian call to compassion even in the face of such violence.
Father Carasala was known for his warm interactions with parishioners, especially the children at Saints Peter and Paul School. Tina Strathman, whose family had close ties to the priest, recalled his friendly demeanor and the joy he brought to occasions like weddings and baptisms. His playful spirit was evident as he often played dodgeball with the schoolchildren, creating lasting memories that will not be forgotten.
Local businesses were equally shocked by the violence that disrupted their peaceful community. Diann Funk, an employee at Seneca Variety, expressed disbelief, noting that such incidents were unheard of in their tight-knit town. The sense of security that residents once felt has been shattered, leaving many to grapple with the harsh reality of loss.
Archbishop Joseph Naumann of the Archdiocese of Kansas City expressed his condolences, describing Father Carasala as a devoted pastor whose death has deeply affected his parishioners, friends, and fellow priests. The archbishop’s sentiments resonate with many who knew Father Carasala, as they come together to heal and support one another in this time of sorrow.
As the community of Seneca mourns, they are reminded of the strength found in their faith and the bonds of love that connect them. Together, they will honor Father Carasala’s legacy, cherishing the memories of a man who dedicated his life to serving others and spreading the message of Christ. In the face of tragedy, they will continue to find hope, healing, and the power of prayer.
For more information on the ongoing investigation and community support efforts, you can visit the Archdiocese of Kansas City or check local news updates from KSHB News.