Army National Guard Officer Files Lawsuit Over Alleged No Christians in Leadership Policy

In a striking legal battle that has captured national attention, Major David Worley of the Idaho Army National Guard is taking a stand against what he claims is a discriminatory policy targeting his Christian beliefs. The lawsuit, filed by Liberty Counsel on January 17, 2023, accuses Idaho Governor Brad Little and military officials of unlawfully removing Worley from his command position based on his faith.

Worley alleges that the Idaho Army National Guard implemented an unconstitutional policy dubbed "No Christians in Command," aimed at identifying military personnel deemed "extremists." This policy reportedly involved scrutinizing the social media profiles of potential command candidates to uncover any "concerning ideologies." According to the lawsuit, this initiative was not only a violation of Worley’s rights but also an infringement on religious freedom within the military.

The saga began when Worley, an infantry officer, decided to run for mayor of Pocatello, Idaho, in 2023. Throughout his campaign, he openly expressed his Christian convictions and moral objections to various social issues, including controversial events like "Drag Queen Story Hours" and the availability of explicit materials in public libraries for minors. Liberty Counsel asserts that all of Worley’s statements were made while off-duty and in his personal capacity, prior to assuming any command role.

The situation escalated when a subordinate service member, identifying as homosexual, filed a complaint against Worley, claiming he felt "threatened and unsafe" due to Worley’s religious beliefs. This complaint led to Worley’s suspension from command in July 2023. The lawsuit contends that military officials pressured him to resign without proper counsel or notice. After consulting with Liberty Counsel, Worley quickly rescinded his resignation.

A subsequent investigation, led by Brigadier General James C. Packwood, ultimately found the allegations against Worley to be "unsubstantiated." Despite this, the investigation recommended that future command candidates undergo public records searches and social media monitoring to identify any "concerning information." Instead of reinstating Worley, Packwood reportedly labeled his religious beliefs as "toxic" and upheld the controversial policy.

Governor Little’s office has not publicly addressed the lawsuit, but a spokesperson for the Idaho National Guard has emphasized that Worley remains employed, retaining his rank, pay, and benefits. The spokesperson also stated that no policy changes have been made, with a review still in progress.

Liberty Counsel’s founder, Mat Staver, has been vocal about the implications of this case, stating that military personnel do not lose their constitutional rights upon serving. He emphasized that the military cannot punish individuals for their sincerely held religious beliefs or target religion for discriminatory treatment. Staver called on Governor Little to ensure the protection of free speech for service members like Worley.

Franklin Graham, the CEO of Samaritan’s Purse, also weighed in on the situation, defending Worley’s right to express his beliefs. Graham pointed out that simply disagreeing with someone does not equate to hatred. He emphasized the importance of sharing truth and love, rooted in Christian teachings, as a means of compassion.

As this legal battle unfolds, it raises critical questions about religious freedom and the treatment of service members within the military. The outcome could have far-reaching implications not only for Major Worley but for the rights of all military personnel who hold religious convictions. The case serves as a reminder of the ongoing struggle for religious liberty in America, particularly in environments where personal beliefs may clash with institutional policies.

For more information on the legal proceedings and updates on this case, you can refer to Liberty Counsel’s official website and stay informed about the latest developments in religious freedom issues across the nation.