NJ Church Abandons Homeless Shelter Initiative Due to Eminent Domain Concerns

In a recent turn of events, Christ Episcopal Church in Toms River, New Jersey, has decided to withdraw its proposal to open a homeless shelter on its property. This decision comes after the local zoning board rejected the church’s request for an exemption needed to operate the 17-bed facility. The rejection was a significant setback for the church, which aimed to provide much-needed support for the homeless community in the area.

The church’s rector, Rev. Lisa Hoffman, expressed her disappointment in a statement, mentioning that the decision was not made lightly. "Bishop Sally French and I agree that it would be best for us not to pursue any further action at this time," Hoffman stated, emphasizing the need to prioritize the well-being of the congregation and the church property. This sentiment echoes a growing concern among churches across the nation about their role in addressing social issues, particularly homelessness.

The church’s ambitious plan to assist the homeless was also hindered by the inability to secure a grant from Ocean County, which would have provided essential resources for operating the shelter. In her remarks, Bishop French noted her gratitude for the church’s efforts, but lamented the obstacles that prevented them from expanding their services to those in need. "We remain committed to the work of gospel justice and look forward to further opportunities to support the community, especially those suffering from homelessness," she stated.

The rejection of the shelter proposal was not the only challenge facing Christ Episcopal Church. The local government had also proposed an eminent domain ordinance aimed at seizing the church property to create a community park and recreation center, which would include various facilities such as a playground and sports courts. This plan has sparked significant public backlash, with many community members voicing their opposition through an online petition that garnered over 9,500 signatures.

In June, the Toms River Zoning Board of Adjustment voted 5-2 against the church’s shelter proposal. Board member Dana Tormollan acknowledged the need for a new shelter in the area but expressed concerns about the suitability of the church’s location for such a facility. "These people need a permanent shelter to go to… They deserve someplace to go, but this is not the right spot for them," she commented.

The church’s attorney, Harvey L. York, had previously suggested that the Episcopal Diocese of New Jersey consider legal action to challenge the zoning board’s decision. However, with the recent withdrawal of the shelter proposal, the church is now focusing on protecting its property and maintaining its mission within the community.

As the situation unfolds, the church remains committed to its core mission of serving the community and addressing the pressing issue of homelessness. The decision to drop the shelter plan, while disappointing, reflects a careful consideration of the church’s resources and responsibilities. In a world where the needs of the vulnerable are often overlooked, Christ Episcopal Church’s efforts to advocate for the homeless serve as a reminder of the vital role faith communities play in social justice.

For more information on efforts to support the homeless in New Jersey, you can visit the New Jersey Coalition to End Homelessness or check out the Episcopal News Service for updates on church initiatives and community support programs.

Author